We show that the large-scale routine use of the fused silica debris shield (FSDS) maintains the ∼100× reduction in damage initiation rate and 70% increase in the install lifetime of a new grating debris shield (GDS) observed during pilot operations. Furthermore, we show that the install lifetimes of recycled GDS optics are nearly tripled using additional mitigation strategies such as expanding mitigation processing to include all damage sites larger than 10 μm (LT10) rather than just larger than 50 μm (LT50) and FSDS. We note that there is still a 50% difference between new and recycled optic installation lifetimes. We show that recycled optics have a 3.5× higher apparent initiation rate than new optics when exposed to nominally identical laser conditions.